Tory Defections to Reform UK Threaten Party Stability, Experts Warn
Nigel Farage's invitation to Conservative defectors to join Reform UK is creating internal instability within the party. Past defections, like Shaun Woodward's move to Labour in 1999 and Dan Poulter's prominent positioning during PMQs in April 2024, illustrate ongoing tensions. Current and recent defectors include Nadine Dorries, Andrea Jenkyns, Jake Berry, Sarah Atherton, Maria Caulfield, Danny Kruger, Malcolm Offord, and Ben Bradley. Their stated reasons focus on opposition to Conservative values, though many previously supported the party's immigration policies, leading some supporters to view their break as hypocritical.
These defectors are often seen as ideological zealots who misunderstand that politics requires compromise and consensus. They may have expectations for payback or rewards, and if these are unmet, they might respond with petulant outbursts potentially embarrassing the Conservative Party. Historical examples such as Churchill's liberal-leaning phase and the 1981 SDP's 'gang of four' are noted exceptions to usual defection patterns. Meanwhile, Kemi Badenoch advocates for the Conservatives to remain resolute and even encourage others to leave if they do not align with the party's direction.
Reform UK is currently bolstered by a wave of defections from both councillors and MPs, a momentum highlighted during their conference at the NEC Birmingham in September 2025. This ongoing shift poses significant challenges for the Conservative Party's unity and future stability.
